Rob O’Connor makes a case for the infamous NFL team behind the love boat scandal. Raph blushes.

Kelsey Djupstrom submits the Olympic gold medalist skeleton racer, but Raph thinks he could do that.

Owen Robinson pitches the eccentric Red Sox player/pothead, but will Raph's Boston bias prevail?

Danielle Radford schools Raph on the legendary pro wrestler who transcended tropes.

Choni Francis submits the controversial basketball brawler, but can Raph get past Choni's iPod Nano?

Nick Dee pitches the hard-partying weekend in Philly, but Raph's more impressed by Nick herself.

Megan Gailey presents the cornerback known for his infamous exit, but will Raph take him seriously?

Alfred Aquino II submits the viral skateboarder, but is Raph too salty about missing his shot?

Lily Du and Paul Robalino join Raph for a story about baseball, sex, and a life-altering switcheroo.

Janie and Katie join Raph to debate whether the underwhelming Olympic skier is a scammer or a hero.